How Many Cubes to Feed Cows in Winter: 20% vs 40% Cubes, Tubs and Cost per Pound of Protein (2026)
Updated Nov 13, 2026 · Independent guide · Not sponsored
Short answer: test your hay or grass first. If it is under about 7% crude protein, cows need a protein supplement. Texas A&M AgriLife's starting points: a dry cow in good condition needs about 1 to 1.5 lb a day of a 40% cube, and a nursing cow about 2 to 3 lb. If she needs energy as well as protein, feed a 20% cube: about 2 to 3 lb for a dry cow and 4 to 6 lb for a wet cow on average-quality hay. Start at no more than 2 lb a day and work up. Compare products by cost per pound of crude protein, not price per bag or ton. In Oklahoma State's example, a 38% supplement cost $0.50 a pound of protein and a 20% supplement $0.75, which came to $0.37 versus $0.55 a cow a day for the same protein.
Does your herd need a supplement at all?
It depends on the forage, not the calendar. Texas A&M AgriLife's Factors and Feeds for Supplementing Beef Cows (Hammack, Gill and Machen, 2020) sorts forage three ways:
| Forage quality | Crude protein (CP) | Energy (TDN) | Supplement need |
|---|---|---|---|
| Low | Under 7% | Under 50% | Usually needed. Dormant warm-season grass and weathered hay often land here in winter. |
| Medium | 7 to 11% | 50 to 57% | Little or none, especially for dry and short-bred cows. |
| High | Above 12% | Above 57% | Usually none, except high-milking cows in low condition. |
What the cow needs from that forage changes with her stage. AgriLife beef specialist Jason Banta's figures: to hold her condition, a dry cow in late gestation needs hay of about 8% protein and 55% TDN, and a lactating cow about 11.5% protein and 62 to 63% TDN. That is why the same hay can be fine for dry fall-weaned cows and short for spring calvers once they calve. A hay test at the AgriLife lab costs $8 to $29 and tells you which side of the line you are on.
Body condition matters as much as hay. The same AgriLife publication says cows below BCS 4 need far more supplement, often more than is affordable, while cows at BCS 4 to 5 need much less and fleshy cows (BCS 6 and up) little if any beyond minerals. Score the herd at weaning with our body condition scoring guide and feed the thin group, not the whole herd.
How many cubes to feed a cow a day
These are starting points from Texas A&M AgriLife, not a ration. The publication's amounts assume a 1,300 lb cow at BCS 5.
| Cow and situation | Supplement | Pounds per cow per day | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry cow, good condition | 40% protein cube | 1 to 1.5 to start | Banta, AgriLife |
| Dry mature cow, medium or better condition, dormant warm-season grass or low-quality hay | High-protein supplement (38–41% cube) | 1 to 2 | Factors and Feeds |
| Same cow on extremely poor forage | High-protein supplement | 3 to 4 | Factors and Feeds |
| Wet (nursing) cow | 40% protein cube | 2 to 3 | Banta, AgriLife |
| Dry cow on average-quality hay, needs protein and energy | 20% range or breeder cube | 2 to 3 | Banta, AgriLife |
| Wet cow on average-quality hay, needs protein and energy | 20% range or breeder cube | 4 to 6 | Banta, AgriLife |
| Thin dry mature cow on poor forage | Medium-protein, high-energy supplement | 3 to 4 | Factors and Feeds |
AgriLife adds that after calving, all of these amounts should roughly double. Start at no more than 2 lb a day and build up slowly, because cows are built to digest grass, and a sudden jump in concentrate can cause acidosis and founder (Banta). Banta also suggests watching the manure: firm patties that stack up mean the cows need more protein.
20% or 40% cubes?
Pick the cube by what is short in the diet:
- Only protein short (plenty of hay or standing grass, cows in decent shape): a high-protein cube, 38 to 41%, usually made from cottonseed or other oilseed meal. AgriLife calls these often the most economical way to get protein into grazing cows, and Banta says a 40% cube is more cost effective when only protein is needed.
- Protein and energy both short (thin cows, poor or short forage, nursing cows): a 20% range or breeder cube, fed in bigger amounts. Nebraska's Rick Rasby calls a 20% cube more of an energy cube, and puts true protein supplements at 28 to 36% protein.
- Read the tag. Cubes under 10% crude fiber are usually higher in energy and are often sold as “breeder” cubes. Some cubes get part of their protein from urea (non-protein nitrogen), and AgriLife notes cows vary a lot in how much of that they turn into usable protein.
- Mix your own. If you can mix and feed it, AgriLife says about 1/3 oilseed meal and 2/3 cracked grain is roughly a 20% cube, and about 3/4 meal and 1/4 grain is roughly a 32% cube.
The trap is feeding a small amount of a 20% cube. AgriLife says 20% cubes have to be fed in full amounts to work; if you can't afford that, feed a smaller amount of a higher-protein supplement instead.
Cost per pound of protein: the math
Oklahoma State's Supplementing Beef Cows (AFS-3010) works an example for an 1,100 lb cow on native range in the last third of pregnancy that is short 0.74 lb of crude protein a day:
| Supplement | Price per ton | Pounds to feed | Cost per cow per day | Cost per lb of protein |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20% protein | $300 | 3.70 | $0.55 | $0.75 |
| 25% protein | $340 | 3.00 | $0.51 | $0.68 |
| 38% protein | $380 | 1.95 | $0.37 | $0.50 |
Choosing the 20% when only protein was needed would have cost about $18 more per cow over 100 days (OSU). Those are OSU's example prices, not today's; the 25% row's cost per pound of protein is our arithmetic on OSU's numbers. The formula is the same for any product: price per ton ÷ (2,000 × protein %). For bags and tubs, use the price divided by the weight in pounds, then divide by the protein %. Nebraska Extension adds that a more concentrated product can also save on delivery, because you haul fewer tons for the same protein.
Supplement cost calculator
Enter up to three products from the feed store tag or quote. Defaults are Oklahoma State's example.
| Product | Price ($) | Pounds in that price (bag, tub or 2,000 for a ton) | Crude protein % | Lb fed per cow per day |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | ||||
| B | ||||
| C |
Cubes vs tubs vs liquid feed
Tubs, blocks and liquids save labor, and AgriLife says that is their main advantage, along with self-limiting intake. The trade-off: they are relatively expensive per unit of nutrient and generally won't fix a large shortfall or support high performance. What AgriLife's Factors and Feeds lists:
| Type | Crude protein | Typical intake per cow per day | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| High-protein cubes | 38 to 41% | 1 to 3 lb | Fed on the ground. Often the cheapest protein. |
| Range / breeder cubes | 12 to 32% (commonly 20%) | 3 to 6 lb | Protein plus energy. |
| Pressed blocks (often 33 lb) | 20 to 40% | 1 to 4 lb | Intake depends on hardness and how many blocks are out. |
| Chemically hardened tubs | 20 to 30% | 1 to 3 lb | Hardness sets intake. |
| Low-moisture (cooked) tubs | 10 to 40% | 0.5 to 1.5 lb | Lowest intake of the tubs and blocks; fairly even across the herd. |
| Liquid supplements | 16 to 40% | Varies | Much of the protein may be urea. Don't let tanks run empty; cows can overeat after a refill. |
Not every cow eats from a tub. A review by Bowman and Sowell (1997), cited by Kansas State, found an average of 19% of cattle ate none of a self-fed block or liquid supplement, versus 5% for hand-fed supplement. Alabama Extension says most tubs weigh 150 to 200 lb (up to 500), mature cattle eat 1 to 4 lb a day depending on the product, hardness and where it sits, and no more than half the crude protein should come from non-protein nitrogen such as urea. AgriLife notes tubs placed near water or loafing areas get eaten faster, and that forage has to be adequate or cattle can overeat them. Track it: tub weight ÷ head ÷ days until empty gives your real intake to put in the calculator above.
How often to feed cubes
Because the amount is small and cows recycle nitrogen, AgriLife says high-protein cubes such as cottonseed meal cubes don't have to be fed every day. The weekly amount can be split and fed every other day, twice a week, or as seldom as once a week, depending on the product and amount. That saves trips and can even out how much each cow gets. 20% range and breeder cubes are different: they are fed in larger amounts and should go out daily, or at least every other day. Banta's advice for any supplement: feed it consistently to avoid digestive problems such as acidosis.
Don't skip minerals and vitamin A
AgriLife puts minerals and vitamins first because they are cheap compared with protein and energy. Warm-season forages can be short on some minerals most of the year, so year-round mineral is the norm. Dry, dormant or weathered forage is typically low in vitamin A, which AgriLife says should be supplied if the shortage is suspected to last more than 30 days.
Using hay as the supplement
Good alfalfa or similar hay (usually 15 to 20% CP) can be limit-fed in place of cubes, AgriLife says, though feeding it free choice wastes the extra protein and gets expensive. Nebraska Extension adds that hay is mainly an energy source: if cows need a lot of energy, more or better hay is usually cheaper than cubes. Our hay calculator estimates tons and bales for the winter, and the feed cost calculator rolls hay and supplement into a cost per cow and a breakeven calf price.
Cold snaps raise energy needs more than protein needs. For extra hay by temperature, wind and wet coats, see how cold is too cold for cattle.
These are Extension rules of thumb and research averages for planning. Your hay test, cow condition and calving season decide the real answer. Work out a ration with your county Extension agent or a nutritionist, and follow feed tag directions.
Common questions
How many pounds of cubes should I feed a cow per day in winter?
Texas A&M AgriLife's starting points: a dry cow in good condition needs about 1 to 1.5 lb a day of a 40% protein cube, and a nursing cow 2 to 3 lb. If she needs energy too, feed a 20% cube at about 2 to 3 lb for a dry cow and 4 to 6 lb for a wet cow on average-quality hay. Start at no more than 2 lb a day and build up.
Should I feed 20% or 40% cubes?
If only protein is short, a 38 to 41% cube is usually the cheaper way to supply it. If cows need both protein and energy, such as thin or nursing cows on poor forage, a 20% range or breeder cube fed in larger amounts fits better (Texas A&M AgriLife). Nebraska Extension calls a 20% cube more of an energy cube.
How do I calculate cost per pound of protein?
Divide the price per ton by the pounds of protein in a ton: 2,000 times the protein percentage. In Oklahoma State's example, a 20% supplement at $300 a ton costs $0.75 per pound of protein and a 38% supplement at $380 a ton costs $0.50.
Are protein tubs worth it compared with cubes?
Tubs save labor, but Texas A&M AgriLife says they are relatively expensive per unit of nutrient and generally won't correct a large shortfall. A review cited by Kansas State found 19% of cattle ate none of a self-fed block or liquid, versus 5% for hand-fed supplement.
Do I have to feed cubes every day?
Not high-protein cubes. Texas A&M AgriLife says the weekly amount of a cottonseed meal type cube can be fed every other day, twice a week, or as seldom as once a week. Range and breeder cubes fed in larger amounts should go out daily or at least every other day.
When do cows need a protein supplement?
When forage is under about 7% crude protein, which AgriLife calls low quality. A dry cow in late gestation needs hay of about 8% protein and 55% TDN to hold condition, and a lactating cow about 11.5% protein and 62 to 63% TDN. Test your hay to know.
Sources
- Texas A&M AgriLife Extension: Factors and Feeds for Supplementing Beef Cows (Hammack, Gill, Machen, EL-5354, 2020) (forage quality bands, BCS effects, cube, block, tub and liquid protein and intake ranges, feeding amounts and frequency, home mixes, minerals and vitamin A)
- AgriLife Today: Producers should prepare for winter supplement needs (Jason Banta, Texas A&M AgriLife) (8% and 11.5% protein needs, 20% vs 40% cubes, pounds per day for dry and wet cows, start at 2 lb or less)
- Oklahoma State University Extension AFS-3010: Supplementing Beef Cows (cost per pound of protein example, 0.74 lb protein shortfall, $18 per cow over 100 days)
- University of Nebraska–Lincoln Beef: Is it okay to feed protein cubes instead of hay? (Rick Rasby) (20% cube as an energy cube, cost per pound of crude protein, delivery cost)
- Kansas State University Beef Tips: Mineral intake and variability (Dale Blasi) (5% vs 19% non-feeders, hand-fed vs self-fed, citing Bowman and Sowell 1997)
- Alabama Cooperative Extension ANR-2669: Self-limiting Feeds for Beef Cattle (Mullenix, Elmore) (tub weights and intake, no more than half of protein from NPN)
Related: how much mineral a cow eats (bag calculator) · how to test hay · body condition scoring · winter hay calculator · feed cost and breakeven calculator · free Winter Hay Plan · how to reduce hay waste · hay and feed tools
The Cattle Range